On Saturday, I return to New Orleans, Louisiana, one of my favorite cities and a place I lived (very) briefly in 1998. Most visits since then have been to see the Cowboys play the Saints and this weekend will be no exception. Before my arrival, I thought I’d give a quick review of the games I’ve attended in reverse order of how “enjoyable” each one was to me as a Cowboys fan. Each of the games I went to was courtesy of my good college friend, Randy, who has had Saints season tickets since 1995. Football fans may recall that the Saints were absolutely horrible before the arrival of Drew Brees in 2006 (didn’t win their first playoff game until 2000!), so the fact that he paid to watch such awfulness is a credit to him and when they finally won the Super Bowl in February 2010, I couldn’t have been happier for him.
Without further ado, here are the games. It turns out all of them are available in their entirety on YouTube, so I embedded videos that should start at the appropriate moment.
THE BLOWOUT AKA 40 FIRST DOWNS
November 10, 2013: New Orleans Saints 49, Dallas Cowboys 17
I arrived in New Orleans on Friday night and I remember telling Randy that I would be focused on watching my Terps that night before turning my attention to the upcoming football game. Fortunately his local bar had all the games on, so I sat at the bar in my Maryland red to watch an early season match up against UConn. Despite my focus on the game, Randy insisted on introducing me to everyone as his Cowboy fan friend.
Anyone familiar with Terrapin basketball knows that they are possibly even more disappointing as a team than my Cowboys. And this night was no different. At one point in the game, my frustration got the best of me as I slapped the bar and knocked over my Guinness. I can’t even remember another time I spilled a beer in public, so I just hung my head in shame when the bartender walked over with a rag.
“You the Cowboys fan?” he asked.
“Uh, yeah…” I responded.
“Clean up your own [bleeping] mess,” he exclaimed as he threw the rag at me and went to pour my next Guinness. I shrugged and thought, that’s fair, as I mopped up the beer. UConn went on to defeat Maryland 78-77.
I know, I know, you want to hear about the Cowboys Saints game… Where to even begin with this one? The Saints got 40 first downs (an NFL record), the Cowboys ran a total of 43 plays! While it was unlikely that the 5-4 Cowboys would go into New Orleans and beat the 7-2 Saints, I don’t think anyone saw this result coming.
Perhaps most representative of this game for me was a sequence late in the 3rd quarter. With the Saints leading 35-10 and the Cowboys with the ball, my ever optimistic self was still envisioning a comeback. But when Tony Romo missed Cole Beasley badly, with the ball landing yards short, my frustration exploded. I jumped out of my seat, yelling, “Come ON!!!!” and everyone around me seemed kind of surprised. It occurred to me that I might be the only one in the entire section still paying close attention. People in New Orleans are always in or ready to be in celebration mode and the unofficial party had already begun, so they all looked up at me and laughed at the silly Cowboys fan still intently focused on a game that was all but over. I looked down at Randy who just chuckled and shook his head. (He’s not a stranger to trash talking, as we’ll see below, but even he couldn’t be bothered at this point in the game.)
Standing there amidst the laughter and heckling, I did something I’m not particularly proud of but that I’ll also never forget. I pulled off my beloved Romo jersey, turned it inside out, and put it back on. And the laughter turned to cheers and applause from the surrounding Saints fans who seemed to enjoy watching my fandom break down before their eyes (possibly because many of them remembered me from previous encounters since Randy’s tickets haven’t moved in years). They were a bit superstitious as well since the Cowboys scored two plays later and then successfully recovered an onside kick, so suddenly they were begging me to put my jersey back on the right way. But in the end it obviously didn’t matter, as the final score attests.
“EMMITT WHO??” AKA “I TOLD YOU THE SAINTS CAME TO PLAY TODAY”
December 6, 1998: New Orleans Saints 22, Dallas Cowboys 3
This was my first time going to the Superdome. I felt reasonably confident going in. The Cowboys were 8-4 and still had the main components of their Super Bowl winning teams from earlier in the decade. The Saints were 5-7, still known as the “aints” to many of their fans, and going nowhere. I’m skeptical that Randy can name the Saints starting QB at that game (Kerry Collins), but he told me repeatedly the day before the game that he believed the Saints were gonna come to play on Sunday.
My quiet confidence got tested early, as the Cowboys were immediately backed up because of a holding penalty on the kickoff. The first play was a handoff to Emmitt Smith, who was dropped for a four yard loss. “EMMITT WHO??” On the next play, Troy Aikman was called for intentional grounding in the endzone, and suddenly the Saints led 2-0. “I TOLD YOU THE SAINTS CAME TO PLAY TODAY!!”
Later in the first quarter, the Cowboys intercepted Collins deep in Saints territory, but after three straight incompletions, they were left to kick a short field goal, briefly giving them the lead, 3-2. A disappointing result from my perspective. “I TOLD YOU THE SAINTS CAME TO PLAY TODAY!!”
The Saints’ offense got going in the second quarter, including an 89 TD pass from Collins to Andre Hastings and went to the half leading 19-3. “I TOLD YOU THE SAINTS CAME TO PLAY TODAY!!”
This was actually Emmitt Smith’s worst day as a Cowboy, with only 6 yards rushing on 15 carries. (His worst day as a pro was actually AGAINST the Cowboys as a Cardinal, when he rushed for -1 yards on 6 carries before Roy Williams broke his collarbone.) Every time Emmitt was dropped for a loss, the large black man next to me jumped out of his seat and yelled down at me (can you guess?)
“EMMITT WHO?? I TOLD YOU THE SAINTS CAME TO PLAY TODAY!!”
THE OVERTIME THRILLER AKA WHAT JUST HAPPENED?
October 4, 2015: New Orleans Saints 26, Dallas Cowboys 20 (OT)
As a fan of a particular team, it’s always fun to look back and tell your kids or your friends something notable about games you witnessed. Think about Colts fans who saw Peyton Manning’s first start or Pats fans who saw Tom Brady replace Drew Bledsoe after Mo Lewis’ devastating hit.
As a Cowboys’ fan, what milestones have I been able to witness personally? I was at the playoff game in Lambeau where Dez did (not) catch the ball. Two years later, I watched those same Packers hand Dak his first playoff loss after Aaron (bleeping) Rodgers converted a 3rd and 20 in the final minute. What else? Oh yes, I got to see Brandon Weeden’s first two starts as a Cowboy after Romo went down with a broken collarbone against the Philadelphia Eagles in 2015.
The Cowboys had started 2-0 and hosted the Atlanta Falcons the following week, a game my whole family traveled down to Arlington to witness. A fast start had the home crowd feeling good, as we led 21-7 early, and 28-14 at the half, but the offense scored zero the rest of the way, ultimately losing 39-28.
Despite that setback, I flew down to New Orleans optimistic as ever. The Saints had started 0-3, so even with our backup QB, I felt good about the Cowboys heading into the game. It was a Sunday night kickoff, so Randy and I spent most of the day wandering through the French Quarter (after beginning with charbroiled oysters at Drago’s).
Upon arrival I got the usual razzing from our seatmates. I’m surprised they keep renewing Randy’s tickets since he keeps bringing me. The defense started out well as we slowed the Saints offense and kept them to one score in the first half and led 10-7. Our offense struggled as well since both Romo and Dez were out with significant injuries. After some halftime adjustments, the Saints closed the gap in the 3rd quarter and then pulled ahead midway through the 4th, 20-13.
The Cowboys were running out of chances as the clock ticked down to the 2 minute warning. It was 4th and 7 on the Saints 17 yard line, when Weeden made the most clutch pass of his entire career (probably), a touchdown strike to a diving Terrance Williams in the back of the endzone. I’d say that the Superdome was stunned into silence but I was making more than enough noise to make up the difference.
Unfortunately, the Cowboys defense saw no need to try to preserve the tie and force the game to overtime, as they let the Saints romp down the field. Fortunately, Saints kicker Zach Hocker also felt no urgency to win the game as he banged the 30 yard field goal attempt off the left upright.
The Saints received the ball to start overtime and running back Khiry Robinson dropped an easy pass from Drew Brees on first down. Cowboys linebacker Andrew Gachkar got injured on the play, but decided to limp off the field rather than stay down and let the medical staff attend to him. The Cowboys defense clearly was confused as new players had to quickly substitute in and when the Saints ran basically the same play, but to the faster CJ Spiller, the game was suddenly over, just seconds into overtime.
I was still high on the euphoria of the Cowboys tying the game and sending it to overtime (and surviving the missed FG) so to see our opportunity to win just vanish in seconds was stunning.
UNDEFEATED NO MORE AKA THE BEST WEEKEND EVER
December 19, 2009: Dallas Cowboys 24, New Orleans Saints 17
On Sunday, December 13, 2009, the Dallas Cowboys fell to 8-5 after losing to the San Diego Chargers, their second loss in as many games. Even more significantly, Demarcus Ware was carted off the field with an apparent neck injury.
To say I was distraught would be a significant understatement. I’d been looking forward to going down to New Orleans the entire season, and now my team was on a two-game losing streak, missing their best player, and facing an undefeated (13-0) machine in their home stadium.
After two days of pouting, I decided I was going all in. Starting that Wednesday, I pulled out every Cowboys jersey I owned and vowed that’s all I would wear from that day forward until I returned from the Big Easy, win or lose.
I flew down on Friday, since the game was the following night. One less day for Ware to recover unfortunately. Randy picked me up at the airport. I had on my Romo jersey as I walked out of the terminal, and he jumped out of his SUV wearing his Brees jersey and the trash talking started. This I expected. What I did not expect was for the person behind him to jump out of his car, also wearing a Brees jersey, to start trash talking both of us! After telling me how badly the Saints would beat the Cowboys, he then turned to Randy and admonished me for the unforgivable sin of picking me up at the airport! “You should make him take a taxi!” This was a theme that was repeated throughout our weekend together.
It seemed like everyone was wearing black and gold. It was quite a sight to behold. The team had rallied the whole city together after the devastation of Hurricane Katrina just four years earlier, and now they were the best team in the NFL.
Randy and I kicked off the evening at Muriel’s, which was the only time the entire weekend that I did not wear a Cowboys jersey. I can be classy when necessary. Then Randy took me away from the French Quarter (which is where all the other Cowboys fans were) to his local drinking establishment, which had none.
The next day began at Drago’s, which has become our traditional go-to place before the game for their charbroiled oysters. Win or lose, we always make sure to eat well the weekend of these games. Randy does plenty of scouting throughout the year looking for the best spots.
The game didn’t kick off until Saturday night, so I decided to try my luck at Harrah’s that afternoon. I found a craps table with another Cowboys fan who was trying his best to make friends with the other players. “Look, tonight, we’re rooting for opposing teams, but right now, we are on the same team! It’s us against the casino! Who’s with me?” He then proceeded to go around the table one by one, asking each person if they were with him. When he got to me, he smiled, “Hey, Cowboy, you’re with me, right?”
I glanced down at my chips, which were laying on the don’t. I cleared my throat and responded, “Actually, I’m betting against the dice.”
He gave me a puzzled look for a moment and then yelled, “Well F&*% YOU!!” Nevertheless, the table stayed cold for hours and I made it out of there with a tidy profit.
I called home to tell my wife the good news and check on the family. “We are completely snowed in!!” Some of you may recall that the 2009-10 winter was pretty rough in the mid-Atlantic (we lived in Maryland at the time), as this was the first of four snowstorms that was at least 12 inches. So while I was having a blast down in New Orleans, my wife was stuck at home under a couple feet of snow with two little kids, five and three at the time. I called my next-door neighbor and told her to send her son to my house with a shovel if he wanted to make a quick $20. Then I found the closest jewelry store so I could turn my winnings into a present for Rachel.
The atmosphere leading up to the game was absolutely electric. Back in the 90s, the stadium would rarely sell out, but now it was hard to find a ticket. The last time I had seen the Cowboys there, it felt almost like a home game because there was so much blue, but this time the Saints’ colors dominated.
The Cowboys jumped on the Saints early, surprising everyone, myself included. First was a touchdown bomb from Romo to Miles Austin just four minutes into the game, and that was followed by a Marion Barber TD run later in the quarter. Meanwhile, the Cowboys defense (which did have Demarcus Ware available) held the prolific Saints’ offense without a first down for the entire first quarter.
As the Cowboys continued to control the ball on offense, I got a little louder, signaling first down each time they moved the chains, until a woman’s voice behind me announced, “The next time that finger comes in front of my face, I’m BITING it off!!”
With time running down in the first half and the Saints driving, the beer man appeared, so I quickly requested two for me and Randy. I looked at what was left of my winnings and decided to try to make some amends with the fans around me, so I asked who wanted a beer. People looked up in some surprise, but I think I got six or eight takers and the beer man happily obliged. As the last beer got handed out, play resumed on the field after the two-minute warning. Whatever amends I had made were instantly lost following the next play, a bad Drew Brees interception by Mike Jenkins.
“HA!!” I yelled as I jumped out of my seat, “That’s karma right there! That’s tainted beer! You got beers? WE GOT THE BALL!!!” I’m still not sure how no beer ended up on me after that outburst.
The Cowboys got the ball to start the second half, leading 17-3, and put together a methodical drive for another touchdown and now it was 24-3. Both sets of fans were stunned by what we were witnessing. The defense held the Saints scoreless in the 3rd quarter, but Brees and the Saints offense finally got going in the 4th. They put together an 80 yard TD drive in just over 3 minutes, and after a Cowboys’ 3 and out, they went 70 yards for a TD in 3 and a half minutes.
Now it was just a one-score game and there were still eight minutes left in the game! As the Cowboys started their next drive on their own 20, the Superdome became the loudest place I have ever been in my life. And that’s when Romo put together the best non-scoring drive (SPOILER!) of his entire career. While it would have been much better for our kicker to NOT clang the ball off the right upright, the fact that Romo milked almost six minutes off the clock was what put the Cowboys in position to win.
Brees still had over two minutes left to get the tying score, but the Cowboys defense kept everything in front of them, and with 12 seconds left, Ware put the exclamation point on the win, sacking Brees, forcing a fumble that the Cowboys recovered, and I was filled with an exhilarating sense of joy and relief.
Randy: Why are you hugging me?
Me: I don’t know, I got no one else to hug…
Randy: Get off me!